气候变化领域集成服务门户(CCPortal): Reply to “Comment on the paper by Buono et al. “Dynamics of degassing in evolved alkaline magmas: Petrological, experimental and theoretical insights” (Earth Science Reviews, 211 (2020), 103402)”

CCPortal

DOI	10.1016/j.earscirev.2021.103654
	Reply to “Comment on the paper by Buono et al. “Dynamics of degassing in evolved alkaline magmas: Petrological, experimental and theoretical insights” (Earth Science Reviews, 211 (2020), 103402)”
	Buono G.; Fanara S.; Macedonio G.; Palladino D.M.; Petrosino P.; Sottili G.; Pappalardo L.
发表日期	2021
ISSN	00128252
英文摘要	In our original paper (Buono et al., 2020), we investigated the dynamics of degassing (e.g., bubble nucleation and growth, degassing styles and regimes) of H2O-, CO2- and H2O-CO2-rich evolved alkaline melts over a wide range of variables (final pressures, decompression rates, volatile compositions and contents, temperatures) through a comprehensive review of previous and new HP (high pressure)-HT (high temperature) decompression experiments. The criticism of Allabar and Nowak regards a restricted part of our results, i.e., those concerning homogeneous bubble nucleation from our new experiments on H2O-rich melts. Their aim is refusing the classical nucleation theory (CNT), widely accepted in literature to explain homogeneous bubble nucleation in magmas, for evolved alkaline melts in favour of the spinodal decomposition. We found that the Authors of the Comment do not provide any new evidence in support of their thesis, but they keep only arbitrary and erroneous conjectures of our new experimental data. As we stated in our original paper, the evaluation of the specific bubble nucleation mechanism (CNT vs. spinodal decomposition) is beyond the scope of our research, as appropriate studies on both experimental and natural products would be necessary to shed light on this complex issue. © 2021 Elsevier B.V.
关键词	Alkaline melts Magma ascent Magma degassing
语种	英语
来源期刊	Earth Science Reviews
文献类型	期刊论文
条目标识符	http://gcip.llas.ac.cn/handle/2XKMVOVA/203978
作者单位	Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia, Sezione di Napoli - Osservatorio Vesuviano, Naples, Italy; University of Naples Federico II, Department of Earth, Environmental and Resources Science, Naples, Italy; Georg-August University of Göttingen, Department of Experimental and Applied Mineralogy, Göttingen, Germany; Sapienza-University of Rome, Department of Earth Sciences, Rome, Italy
推荐引用方式 GB/T 7714	Buono G.,Fanara S.,Macedonio G.,等. Reply to “Comment on the paper by Buono et al. “Dynamics of degassing in evolved alkaline magmas: Petrological, experimental and theoretical insights” (Earth Science Reviews, 211 (2020), 103402)”[J],2021.
APA	Buono G..,Fanara S..,Macedonio G..,Palladino D.M..,Petrosino P..,...&Pappalardo L..(2021).Reply to “Comment on the paper by Buono et al. “Dynamics of degassing in evolved alkaline magmas: Petrological, experimental and theoretical insights” (Earth Science Reviews, 211 (2020), 103402)”.Earth Science Reviews.
MLA	Buono G.,et al."Reply to “Comment on the paper by Buono et al. “Dynamics of degassing in evolved alkaline magmas: Petrological, experimental and theoretical insights” (Earth Science Reviews, 211 (2020), 103402)”".Earth Science Reviews (2021).