气候变化领域集成服务门户

Menu

When search suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select.Search

Search

Sign InQuick LinksNewsSportsRadioMusicListen LiveTVWatch

news

Top StoriesLocalClimateWorldCanadaPoliticsIndigenousOpinionThe NationalBusinessHealthEntertainmentScienceCBC News InvestigatesGo PublicAbout CBC NewsBeing Black in CanadaMore

Ottawa argues youth-led climate change lawsuit too broad to be tried in court | CBC News LoadedBritish ColumbiaOttawa argues youth-led climate change lawsuit too broad to be tried in courtMore than a dozen young Canadian activists claim Ottawa has violated their fundamental rights by contributing to the warming planet, and demanding a national plan to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.Youth from across the country claim federal officials are violating their rights to life, liberty, equalityJon Hernandez · CBC News · Posted: Sep 30, 2020 1:11 PM EDT | Last Updated: September 30, 2020Nine of the 15 activists suing the Canadian government over its alleged inaction on climate change stand on the steps of the Vancouver Art Gallery on Oct. 25, 2019, after filing their lawsuit in federal court. (Ben Nelms/CBC)Social Sharing

Federal lawyers argue that a lawsuit alleging the Canadian government has violated the charter rights of 15 youth is far too broad to be heard in court and should be thrown out.

The case, La Rose et al. v. Her Majesty the Queen, was initially filed on Oct. 25, 2019, and involves more than a dozen children and teens from across Canada who are making a relatively novel legal argument — that their rights to life, liberty, security and equality are being violated because Ottawa has not done enough to protect against climate change.

Hearings began in a federal court in Vancouver on Sept. 30 and are expected to last two days. Justice Michael Manson will then decide if the case should be heard in a federal court.

In the defence submission, federal lawyer Joseph Cheng said greenhouse gas emissions are cumulative and a worldwide problem that affects all countries, and so Canada cannot act alone to resolve the impact of climate change.

Cheng argued the plantiffs case was not justiciable,  meaning that it falls well beyond what the courts can meaningfully adjudicate. He said the courts are best suited to address individual laws — not complex issues like climate change.

TODAY: Attorneys for Canada youth plaintiffs in La Rose v. Her Majesty the Queen head to court! Watch LIVE starting at 8:30 am PDT, as they demand the right to a stable climate! Register here: a href= https://t.co/kBBgsMVtE6 https://t.co/kBBgsMVtE6 /a a href= https://t.co/yYot9M3GjM https://t.co/yYot9M3GjM /a

The defence referred to a similar lawsuit filed against Canada over its failure to meet emissions targets under Kyoto Protocol on climate change. In that case, a federal judge dismissed the suit, concluding that was no practical way of enforcing a government to meet its climate goals.

The plaintiffs ask directly for this court to supervise the development and implementation of policy that would engage matters that would take it so far beyond the limits of its institutional capacities, and directly into the political arena, said Cheng.

CBC News has previously reported that the federal government urged a judge to throw out the case, but to no avail. 

The statement of claim was filed the day teen climate activist, Greta Thunberg, visited the Vancouver and led a climate strike rally attended by thousands.

The claim says that  despite knowing for decades that carbon emissions cause climate change and disproportionately harm children, the government continued to allow emissions to increase at a level incompatible with a stable climate capable of sustaining human life and liberties.

There is no explicit environmental right in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. 

The young plaintiffs want a judge to rule that such a right is implicit, as with a number of other rights, such as sexual orientation. They claim the government has infringed on their constitutional rights to life, liberty and security of the person by standing idle as the climate shifts.

Plaintiff Haana Edenshaw, 17, of the Haida Nation, says she is experiencing the effects of climate change on her very doorstep in the village of Masset on Haida Gwaii off B.C. s North Coast.

The water comes right up past our porch, it goes by the door of my room, and it s really scary because it s just going to keep on getting worse every year, Edenshaw told Laura Lynch, host of CBC Radio s What on Earth.

My rights are frankly being violated and just knowing that is very empowering — knowing that I have the right to security of person, knowing that I m entitled to clean water and clean air, she added.

The stakes are high. If the young people win, a court could force the government to overhaul its plans, reducing Canada s harmful emissions more rapidly and potentially ending fossil fuel industry subsidies.

This case — it s the only way forward, plaintiff Ira Reinhart-Smith, 16, told What on Earth.

We can t wait for the government to keep saying, We ll make a plan that will be up to the most current science. We need them to be forced to make a plan that s to the current science, because unless the courts are ordering them to do that, we ve seen in the past they re not going to follow up on the promises, said Reinhart-Smith, of Caledonia, N.S.

Reinhart-Smith and the others in the case were brought together by Our Children s Trust, a non-profit public interest law firm based in Oregon that has helped organize similar lawsuits in the United States and elsewhere. 

The plaintiffs are from B.C., Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia and the Northwest Territories. 

For more on this story, tap here to listen to the Sept. 27 episode of What on Earth with Laura Lynch.

With files from What on Earth, Sarah Lawrynuik, Bridgette Watson and the Canadian Press

Related Stories Top stories from British Columbia B.C. Liberal candidate accused of seeking personal info to request mail-in ballots for voters Indigenous designers in B.C. outraged over claims of authenticity by non-Indigenous competitor Why the positivity rate — a key metric for charting COVID-19 s spread — is giving reason for hope in B.C.Footer LinksMy AccountProfileCBC GemNewslettersAbout CBC AccountsConnect with CBCFacebookTwitterYouTubeInstagramMobileRSSPodcastsContact CBCSubmit FeedbackHelp Centre

Audience Relations, CBC
P.O. Box 500 Station A
Toronto, ON
Canada, M5W 1E6

Toll-free (Canada only):
1-866-306-4636

It is a priority for CBC to create products that are accessible to all in Canada including people with visual, hearing, motor and cognitive challenges.

Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem.